Peluso’s Italian Restaurant

Reviews

• Elizabeth M.

  star star star star star 26 May 2026

  Definitely my favorite pizza place in Columbus!! I've been coming here for about 20 years and could seriously eat here everyday!! You feel like you're at home when you walk in...and the waitresses are so friendly and will make you feel at home even if you've never eaten there before.  
  
  * Came on a Saturday night to pick up a large Deluxe pizza to go. The Deluxe is always my go to pizza!! Whether i'm dining in and getting the 10" special with a salad and drink or grabbing it to go. My favorite part of the pizza is the crust!! It's super thin, crunchy & always cooked just right. I love the mountain of veggies, sausage and pepperoni on the pizza.  And the slices on the large pizza are HUGE!!
  
  * Another added bonus is their college room in the back of the restaurant. They literally have EVERY COLLEGE represented on every wall.  It's pretty cool to find your alma mater.
  
  * Lastly, they have the best sweet tea ever!!! If you like good sweet tea with diabetic sugar levels, then this is the place for you!! It's really good!!! :)

• Melissa P.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 24 May 2026

  I've been looking for good pizza that isn't from a chain. So I decided to order from here. The pizza reminded me of a Tony's frozen pizza with an overkill of Oregano. The crust was definitely. Or hand done or made in-house. I also ordered a hoagie. Definitely didn't expect it to be as small as it was, but it did taste pretty good. I X'd the mustard and added lettuce and tomato. Fries that came with it were pro good too. But I won't be ordering pizza from here. That's for sure. Huge upset.

• Rylee T.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  This place was absolutely disgusting!! Today my friends and I went to lunch. The first thing I noticed was that the establishment was not very clean. I had ordered the spaghetti lunch special which also came with a side salad. The lettuce was very old. Then while they were "cooking" our food, I looked over and they literally were putting all the food in the microwave!!! I'm still in shock that I saw this  but when we got the food, it tasted horrible. It was super watery and the flavor was bad!
  I definitely do not recommend this place!

• Jennifer Rucker B.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  I will not be eating there again.  I hope you don't either.  The menu does not allow you to choose your soup or salad dressing.  There is only one salad dressing...ranch....for an Italian place.  Bread arrived cold. Salad was subpar with wilted lettuce and two tiny pieces of tomato but grossly enough the container of dressing was in my salad.  Great way to get sick. I ordered minestrone soup but it was cold and greasy.  The manacoti was slightly above room temperature and noodle portion was sticky and heavy.  My mom order raveoli.  Ugh. Never seen anything like it.  Heavy handed with the herbs. The pasta is disgusting.  It is sticky and heavy.  The sauce was cold.  Her salad was no better than mine.  We paid close to $30 bucks to eat cold garlic bread and crackers.  I've had better meals at Waffle House.

• Daniel H.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 18 May 2026

  The pizza was okay. The place looks a mess and needs a renovation really bad. Bugs everywhere and the bathroom is really nasty.